Modern

The Frugal Foodie

From

The Frugal Foodie

season

1

episode

10

Lemon Self Saucing Pudding

With

Steph De Sousa

Aussie lemon self-saucing pudding: sponge above, hot lemon sauce below. Winter dessert.

SERVES

4

Lemon self saucing pudding

About this recipe

Justine Schofield's Australian self-saucing pudding. The batter goes into the dish first and a hot lemon syrup poured over the top, the two layers swapping places in the oven. Out comes a sponge floating on a tart lemon sauce. Winter dessert, eaten with cold cream.

The self-saucing pudding (also called pudding-in-a-pudding, hot fudge cake or magic pudding depending on the region) is the broader Anglo-baking category that defines the dish: a single mixed batter that separates during baking into a baked sponge layer on top and a syrup layer on the bottom. The Australian version skews towards lemon and chocolate; the British version often uses treacle or golden syrup.

The physics of the separation is the kitchen magic. The cake batter (lighter than the hot syrup poured over it) floats to the top of the dish as the oven heat sets the structure; the syrup sinks to the bottom and concentrates as the batter above bakes through. The result, when scooped from the dish, is sponge on the spoon with sauce pooling at the bottom of the bowl.

The hot-syrup-over-cold-batter technique is non-negotiable. The syrup needs to be near-boiling when it goes over the room-temperature batter; cold syrup would sink slowly and produce a soggy layer rather than a distinct sauce. Lemon juice and zest in both the batter and the syrup give the dessert its signature double-citrus impact: bright sponge, sharp sauce. Bake at 180 for thirty-five minutes; serve hot from the oven with cold cream or vanilla ice cream. The contrast in temperature is the second magic. A glass of Riesling for the adults.

Ingredients

- Cake

- 2 White Mill cups Self-raising Flour

- 1/2 White Mill cup Caster Sugar

- zest of 2 Market Buy Lemons

- 3/4 Farmdale cup Milk

- 50g Pure Valley melted Butter

- 1 Lodge Farm Egg

- Juice of 1 Market Buy Lemon

- The Olive Tree Olive Oil

- Sauce

- 1/2 cup White Mill Sugar

- zest of 2 Market Buy Lemons

- juice of 3 Market Buy Lemons

- 2 cups boiling water

- 2 tbsp White Mill Corn Flour

- Ice Cream

- I x can Farmdale sweetened Condensed Milk

- 1 tsp White Mill Vanilla Essence

- 600ml Farmdale Thickened Cream

- zest of 2-3 Market Buy Lemon

Method

1. Let’s start by whipping up the cake batter! in a bowl, add the Lemon juice, Lemon zest, Caster Sugar, melted Butter, Egg, and Milk. Whisk it all together until it’s smooth and looking like a lemony dream.

2. Now, add your Self-Raising Flour to the mix and stir until everything is well combined and you’ve got a lovely, thick batter.

3. Spray your slow cooker with a bit of Olive Oil to stop the cake from sticking—it’ll make serving so much easier later

4. Pour your cake batter into the slow cooker and spread it out evenly over the bottom - this is where the magic begins!

5. Next, mix the Lemon juice, Sugar, boiling water, and Corn Flour - here comes the fun part—gently pour this lemony liquid over the back of a soup spoon or your spatula onto the cake batter, it’ll sink down and create a delicious sauce as it cooks.

6. Place a tea towel over the top of your slow cooker (this helps catch condensation and keeps the cake fluffy), then pop on the lid. Cook on high for 2 hours or until the cake is set and the top is golden.

7. Once the pudding is ready, serve it up warm, making sure to scoop up some of that amazing Lemon sauce from the bottom. Enjoy the perfect balance of sweet and tart in every bite with a side of the 3 ingredient no-churn Lemon Ice-cream.

8. Keywords

9. lemon self saucing pudding, best lemon self saucing pudding, citrus self saucing pudding, easy lemon self saucing pudding, slow cooker recipes, desserts

Steph De Sousa

Steph De Sousa cooks as The Frugal Foodie, building recipes around what's already in the pantry and the produce nobody wants to throw out. Her style is straightforward and budget-aware without being austere: roast vegetable peelings, second-day rice, a freezer worked properly. She brings practical home rhythms to Savour and Wander.

Inspiration Starts Here

Join the Savour & Wander Club for recipes, travel notes and first access to future member content.

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

CONTACT US

hello@savourandwander.com

Terms of service

Privacy Policy

© 2026 Savour & Wander. All Rights Reserved.

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

CONTACT US

hello@savourandwander.com

Terms of service

Privacy Policy

© 2026 Savour & Wander. All Rights Reserved.

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

  • SAVOUR & WANDER

    RECIPES

CONTACT US

hello@savourandwander.com

Terms of service

Privacy Policy

© 2026 Savour & Wander. All Rights Reserved.